Score: 5

"Suggestions"

submission: StarBaron - Skirmish

date: July 23, 2008

Could turn out to be a really cool game, just please fix these things:
1) obviously put the sound in there, but you already know that.
2) change the interface a little so that youre not always accidentally clicking on planets all the time when you don't intend to. It gets really frustrating, especially since its real time and mistakes like that cost you. Either that or make it less crowded.
3) improve the way the planets and ships look. With a game like this that already has gameplay down, a little aesthetics will go a long way. It really won't be that hard, just make the planets colored with rudimentary surface features, and put a little more detail into the ships.
4) maybe you want it included in the game play, but I find it annoying that you can't change a ships course until it carries out its last command. This especially sucks when you can accidentally send them the wrong way due to the second problem I listed above. If you want it this way keep it, but I think the game suffers for it personally.
5) i really like your idea of being able to change the planets specifications, and I like how the change takes a little while to come into effect. I'm sure its an idea you've already considered, but it might be cool to include different kinds of ships in the game that each have a specific kind of planet that they are good at taking out, and have different kinds of planet specifications for making these various kinds of ships.

Hope you finish it soon, I enjoyed what you have so far.

Score: 10

"READ THIS, SOMETHING YOU SHOULD KNOW!!!"

submission: XENO TACTIC

date: June 2, 2008

Please heed this it concerns you, I think you've been ripped off. Check out the game at this address:

http://www.kongregate.com/games/preec ep/desktop-tower-defense-1-5

Somebody changed the objects and added a few new modes but the kinds of towers and their balances as well as the kinds of creeps, the order in which they spawn, their HP and speed, and the money they give is all exactly the same. The game is credited to a guy named preecep. Just thought you should know.

Score: 1

"Just kind of boring"

submission: Edgar N' Locke 07

date: May 28, 2008

Sorry guys, content wasn't profound enough to warrant a cartoon. It was kind of lame.

Score: 5

"The first was better"

submission: Xeno Tactic 2

date: May 7, 2008

This is a cool game, but the first one is hands down the best defense game on newgrounds. Having multiple upgrade options is a cool idea, but you should actually put numerical amounts on there instead of filling up a bar. The way you made it in this one makes it hard to gauge which structures are better than others. One very annoying aspect of this game is that the towers sometimes spin in the wrong direction when trying to acquire their targets and never end up getting a single shot off. You should make it like the first one where there isn't any target acquisition at all. Aside from that it just doesn't seem to be well balanced, no matter what you do in this one it always seems like there is a level or two that just cannot be dealt with. Obviously losing a wave or two isn't fatal, but its lame when you know something is coming and that you can't do anything about it.

Score: 4

"indifferent"

submission: *Hyperanimation! Ep. 1

date: March 30, 2008

To tell you the truth the most impressive thing in this was the few seconds of that song by Between the Buried and Me. I can't say I really enjoyed anything besides that. 2/5

Score: 7

"Bugged"

submission: Fratboy Girlfriend TD

date: December 13, 2007

There's some kind of bug that keeps the guys that spawn from being hit by the towers. They just walk right through and the towers never shoot at them. Otherwise I liked it.

Score: 3

"Unoriginal"

submission: Armageddon-Earth's Fate

date: September 30, 2007

Decently animated, but without anything original to it. The main characters look, the fact that he uses an over sized sword, and all the fighting moves he executes are anime cliches. That's really my only complaint. Everything was fine except for the endlessly overused content of your submission.

Score: 0

"Dont listen to that punisher01 guy, he's a moron"

submission: Primal War 13

date: July 19, 2007

I've been following this series since you started, and I'm really impressed with how your flash has improved. This one is probably my favorite in the series. Excellent drawing, really good fighting choreography, and dramatic camera angles. You get better each time so rather than tell you how to improve I want to caution you about something. Please DONT EVER allow elements of anime drawing into your flash. You have a very fresh and unique style and it would be tragic if you allowed something as rehashed as anime to pollute it. Keep making them.

Score: 8

"Nice flash, but..."

submission: Trichinosis

date: June 8, 2007

Well put together, original idea, good flash. However, this kind of came across as passive aggressive diatribe. You present these facts, and then you tell people to think about the world around them and do something positive, as if that would be all it takes to change things. You take for granted that your position is the correct one, that what you think about the world is correct and that what you do and think to be positive is in fact positive. I don't disagree with your views sir, but people do think and do positive things, they just think and prioritize differently. What would change things is an accessible and trustworthy education about the world and realistic solutions (realistic, not idealistic) to its problems.
The message you deliver in your flash only riles those who already agree with you and alienates those who don't. Being shocking and accusatory like this just makes people defensive and unwilling to listen or take your position seriously. In this way it harms the way to the changes you're calling for. Your heart is in the right place, but approaches to change like this one are very numerous and rarely effective.
Keep up the good flash.

Score: 10

"Excellent Excellent Excellent!"

submission: O-two

date: April 1, 2007

You get a well deserved 5 sir. Huge points for originality.